Pros: True to size (I ordered a 6.5 and it fits exactly as expected.) The shoes appear to be well made - no left over glue or thread anywhere. The dye is consistent throughout the shoe, no blotches. I've worn these for a few weeks now and they're holding up very well. They are of average comfort - about what you'd expect for a boot with a heel. I can wear these for a few hours without complaint. And have I mentioned they're adorable? :) I'm usually leery of things with buckles, but these don't look cheesy and don't have that cheap look I hate. I ordered brown so it goes with almost every outfit I own, which is very convenient.

Cons: No real cons I can find. They're a decent price, fit nice, wear well. If I could tell the manufacturer anything, it'd be to add some padding on the heel so I could wear them all day long, but that's what store bought insoles are for. ;)